Athens and Sparta: Are They the Same or Different?

Subject: Social Studies

Lesson Length: 1 hour

Topic: Greek City-States

Grade Level: 3, 4, 5

Standards / Framework:

Brief Description: Students will identify the similarities and differences of Greek city-states: Sparta and Athens.

Know Before You Start: Students should have some understanding of the different city-states that developed throughout Ancient Greece; specifically Athens and Sparta.

Hook: Display the words: men, women, and kids. Brainstorm what daily life looks like for these 3 groups of people in America today. Which responses would not exist in Sparta or Athens? Which responses would only exist in either Sparta or Athens? Imagine and discuss what life must have been like during Ancient Greek times.

Activity: In pairs, students will create a two-panel comic comparing one aspect of life in Athens or Sparta with their own life and experiences. Topics may include: government, gender roles, role of children etc.

  • Panel 1: Using the sample comic as a guide, depict one aspect of life in Athens or Sparta.
  • Panel 2: Illustrate how the depiction in Panel 1 compares to your current life. For example, you might depict your appreciation for the right to vote in our country.

Closure: Have student pairs briefly present their comics to the class. Have the Athens comics go first, then the Sparta comics. As an exit ticket, have students decide which city-state they would prefer to be a part of and why.

Differentiation:

  • Allow students to use a Venn Diagram to compare life in Ancient Greece to the present day. 

  • Provide visuals as needed.

  • Provide sentence frames as needed.

  • Allow students to work in small groups. 

  • Allow students to use the speech-to-text feature as needed.

Resources:

  • Comic for print or display: Comic.
  • Venn Diagrams: Option 1, Option 2.
  • Teacher should ensure an even distribution between Athens and Sparta.
  • Teacher may assign city-state and perspective to student pairs.

Suggested Content Packs:

Suggested Story Starters: